Skyrocketing equipment costs coupled with shrinking manpower continue to cripple volunteer fire companies across Pennsylvania.
On Tuesday, Oct. 6, this ongoing dilemma dominated discussion during the 111th annual Convention of Municipal Officials of Lebanon County, held at the Lebanon Valley Expo Center & Fairgrounds. About 100 municipal officials attended.
Steve Krause, president of the local municipal association and a South Lebanon Township supervisor, addressed the issue before introducing guest speaker Rob Brady, president of Robb Consulting LLC. His Dauphin County-based company specializes in public safety merger, consolidation, and regionalization consulting for municipal, volunteer, and nonprofit fire, EMS, rescue squad, and emergency management organizations.
“I think there isn’t a municipality or town out there that isn’t struggling with fire protection, whether it be manpower shortages or the skyrocketing costs of equipment. We’re all looking for creative ways to do it,” Krause said, adding that his municipality is no different than any other across Pennsylvania.
“We went through a merger process and we’re still working through that centralizing in one or two locations. We’re trying to right size our facilities, but again our bigger struggles are responders especially at the critical times during the workday when there aren’t a lot of volunteers available.”

Even with adequate equipment for an emergency response, weekday daytime manpower is problematic for smaller counties like Lebanon, according to Krause.
“It’s still, you know, a contentious topic depending on who you talk to but it’s something that needs constant attention, and we as municipal officials have an obligation to provide those services to our communities,” Krause said. “You can say, ‘Well, we have mutual aid,’ but again, at the end of the day, who shows up with those trucks? Sometimes you’ll get one truck and one driver. That’s what you get.”
Brady echoed Krause’s comments, noting there are between 2,300 and 2,400 volunteer firefighter companies statewide and only 30,000 volunteers across Pennsylvania, down from 270,000 in the 1970s.
“When you consider the fact that we have about 2,300 to 2,400 active volunteer fire companies, that doesn’t divide up too well when you look at the number of people per organization,” Brady said. “We’re always looking at the person that can don a piece of breathing apparatus and drag a hose line down the hallway. All the other people are extremely important parts of the system but at the end of the day you need somebody to extinguish the fire and when you look and you take those numbers and you dig into the data you have even less people who are available. In some communities, in some places we’re actually truly seeing an aging out of the members.”
He noted fewer volunteers lead to higher call volume, longer response times, and increased burnout among the remaining members.
After highlighting various mindsets prevailing today that are detrimental to volunteer fire service, he dove into responses to this issue by municipal leaders.

He said there is a slow continuation of the merger and consolidation of nonprofit fire and EMS organizations, with some signing pre-merger memorandums of understanding to determine if a partnership will work. He noted there is shared volunteer manpower and shared operational leadership under this model.
“We’re starting to see a more formal approach to people partnering with neighbors before they actually step in to do something, a merger, consolidation, or multi-administration,” Brady said. “They’re actually putting stuff … into an MOU to look at joint staffing, shared services, shared facilities, those types of things.”
While Act 172 volunteer firefighter tax credit and stipend programs have helped address what Brady said is the big gaping hole that’s still bleeding because of a lack of manpower, he urged caution in using stipends for training since some of those initiatives are only a temporary solution.
“It’s working to a certain extent, but it’s not a foolproof solution to the problem. But it’s, once again, … a step in the process and it’s a step that’s better. Every time we take a step in making ourselves better, we’re doing something,” said Brady. He said they’re building the relationships needed to get them to the next level.
Brady noted youth must be targeted as the lifeblood of a fire service organization.

“We’re looking and we’re seeing more school districts and the tech schools looking at job re-entry programs, more stuff with students for fire- and EMS-related, but it goes down to one thing. It costs tax dollars. Okay, the implementation of these programs costs money,” Brady said. “There’s a lot of discussion, but there’s more and more people looking at implementing smaller programs, doing more things on the local level, looking at creating that next generation of first responders.”
He said going solo is no longer an option for many more communities due to “rising capital fire service costs with no end in sight for apparatus, equipment, and facilities.”
“Operational staffing is starting to become a necessity,” he said.
That has led some to seek what he called a multi-municipal solution involving oversight and funding via a local authority. Brady said these authorities are being considered, including several that formed recently to deliver EMS services.
“I will tell you there are places that have given up on their volunteers. It’s an unfortunate reality again. They have given up and we’re going to start to process hiring our own career firefighters,” he said. “That is just where, once again, where we are. This is not a doom-and-gloom presentation, but I think to educate you to understand what we’re seeing. Authorities are being created for the delivery of EMS services. People are looking for different tools in the toolbox.”
Annville Township manager Candie Johnson said she remembers a conversation about paid firefighters some 30 years ago when she started working in municipal government.
“I remember saying, ‘Well then, we’re going to have to close up as a municipality because we won’t be able to afford it.’ And I think now 30 years later, here it is,” Johnson said, adding that Annville Cleona Fire Department is searching for a paid administrator. “But you gotta pay for it.”

She said Brady was asked to address municipal leaders because the time to act is now.
“I think the reason you’re here today is to let elected officials understand. You might not have raised taxes, but you have to care because you’re going to have to. We’ve had police departments merge. We’ve made regional departments, but you’re going to have to be prepared for the worst. And it’s not the worst, it’s good for our community, but you have to be financially ready for it, because it’s coming and it’s coming quickly,” she said.
Other convention sessions
Other sessions included presentations on how to fund municipal recreation, conservation, and trail projects via state grants, an overview of the statewide agricultural security area and farmland preservation program, and an update from a representative of the Pennsylvania State Association of Township Supervisors, the parent organization to the local association of municipal officials.
Krause told LebTown that the organization’s purpose is to gather with neighboring municipalities to discuss issues impacting each other and find ways to collaborate.
“The members of the county association have a lot in common,” Krause said. “But we don’t often get to talk outside this room as local municipalities. This gives us a chance to find common ground, common solutions and see if there are ways for us to reduce redundancies with our equipment.”
Questions about this story? Suggestions for a future LebTown article? Reach our newsroom using this contact form and we’ll do our best to get back to you.

Join our community of local news champions.
Cancel anytime.
Monthly
🌟 Annual
- Still no paywall!
- Fewer ads
- Exclusive events and emails
- All monthly benefits
- Most popular option
- Make a bigger impact
Already a member? Log in here to hide these messages
Free local news isn’t cheap. If you value the coverage LebTown provides, help us make it sustainable. You can unlock more reporting for the community by joining as a monthly or annual member, or supporting our work with a one-time contribution. Cancel anytime.

















