Loading audio player...

While going through items in the basement of Cornwall United Methodist Church, historian Nancy Ladd came across a treasure trove – literally.

She found a large metal chest containing bundles of papers tied up with string – some from as early as the 1700s.

“They had information about everyone that worked on this building. It was built in 1877, finished in 1878. I just loved finding this information. I love history.”

The discovery gave Ladd a glimpse into the people and decisions that shaped the church, whose roots stretch back more than 230 years. Drawing on the documents, she has pieced together the story of a congregation that has grown and changed while maintaining its place in the community.

The church at 50 Freeman Drive, Cornwall, dates to 1793, when it was established as Cornwall Methodist Episcopal Church, a nod to its English roots. By 1828, congregant Mrs. Thomas Bird Coleman had organized a Sunday school. After her death in 1830, her husband gave an acre of ground to the church for its first permanent home.

Read More: (April 2025) Who Knew? "Bird" or "Burd"?

“On the site of our present stone structure, a plain brick building 35 by 40 feet was erected for the price of $1,400,” Ladd wrote in a detailed history of the church.

As the congregation grew, however, the modest brick building could no longer accommodate everyone. Within three decades, it was expanded and remodeled to hold more than 300 people. Even that proved insufficient, prompting heirs of the Coleman family to offer financial assistance toward a new church. They agreed to make up the difference if the congregation contributed as much as possible toward the project.

Just eight years after the building had been enlarged, it was razed in 1877. The following year, a new stone church was completed at a cost of approximately $50,000. Its main structure was dedicated on Oct. 20, 1878.

Today, the building’s history can be seen in details throughout the church, from its stained glass to the bell in its tower. Ladd proudly displays some of the artifacts she unearthed in the chest and enjoys sharing the stories behind them.

She described the original pipe organ, a gift from Anne and Robert Coleman, which was installed in the rear of the sanctuary in 1879, then moved to the front of the space in 1896. It has since been replaced by a modern organ.

She also highlighted the bell in the church’s 84-foot tower.

Installed in 1926, it originally served a practical purpose at Bird Coleman Furnace, where it called employees to work. Church members continue to ring it today.

The building’s stained-glass windows offer another reminder of the care that went into its construction. Installed in the late 1930s, they include a large rose window that decorates the rear of the sanctuary.

“That was made from glass imported from Europe,” Ladd said. “They didn’t spare any expense.”

The church has continued to adapt to the needs of its congregation. In 1998, an addition provided office and classroom space, a new fellowship hall and kitchen, and an elevator connecting the basement with the second-floor sanctuary.

Although much has changed over the centuries – including its name – Cornwall United Methodist Church remains a place of worship and fellowship.

The building itself continues to draw attention, said the Rev. Deanna Geiter, church pastor, who credits its striking stone facade with attracting visitors who want to see the historic space.

“If you’re driving from Route 72, it’s breathtaking when you come upon the church. We’ve had people who come just because they want to see this space,” she said.

While the building connects the congregation to its past, its activities reflect the needs of the present. Members gather for an 8 a.m. Sunday service in the first-floor chapel or a 10:30 a.m. service in the sanctuary.

Church activities include women’s Bible study, men’s group, and other ministries, and during the week, the church opens its doors to community groups, including Bible2School, which provides faith-based lessons to elementary school students during the school day.

“We have Scouts who meet here, and we have an active youth group,” said Geiter. “Our youth group has a lot of students not from this church.”

The church’s connections extend beyond its building, too. Each August, its annual peach festival draws a crowd, providing an opportunity to welcome the wider community.

“We have hundreds of people who come to that,” Ladd said. “It’s a big outreach for us.”

Throughout the year, the church collects food for Lebanon County Christian Ministries and looks for other ways to address local needs. Last year, members partnered with Cornwall Elementary School for a holiday food drive after learning that some families were experiencing food insecurity. The church plans to continue the partnership this year.

The effort reflects the congregation’s desire to build relationships and help its neighbors.

“We’re looking at the needs in the community and trying to bridge out,” Geiter said. “We want to build even more partnerships.”

That commitment to connection is also behind Second Saturday Cornwall Connect, a new ministry that launched in early October. Held one Saturday evening a month in the fellowship hall, the gathering features music, scripture and testimonies, offering people an opportunity to spend time together.

“We have contemporary music, and it’s a time for people to enjoy fellowship, to sit and have a conversation,” Geiter explained.

For a congregation with roots dating to the 18th century, the new ministry represents another chapter in a long history of bringing people together. The building preserves reminders of those who came before, while the people inside continue to find new ways to serve their community.

“This is a busy place,” Ladd said. “There’s always something happening here.”

For more information on the church, visit cornwallchurch.org.

Questions about this story? Suggestions for a future LebTown article? Reach our newsroom using this contact form and we’ll do our best to get back to you.

Support Lebanon County journalism.

Cancel anytime.

  • Still no paywall!
  • Fewer ads
  • Exclusive events and emails
  • All monthly benefits
  • Most popular option
  • Make a bigger impact

Already a member? Log in here to hide these messages

Local news is a public good—like roads, parks, or schools, it benefits everyone. LebTown keeps Lebanon County informed, connected, and ready to participate. Support this community resource with a monthly or annual membership, or make a one-time contribution. Cancel anytime.

Cathy Molitoris lives in Lancaster and has written for local, regional, national, and international publications. When she’s not writing, she enjoys life with her husband, their two grown daughters, two cats and one very short, very round Corgi.

Sound Off

What’s your take on this story?

Anyone can comment. Sign your name or post as a guest. Please keep it on topic and respectful.


★ MEMBERMembers’ comments are featured.