This article is shared with LebTown by content partner Spotlight PA.
By Ed Mahon of Spotlight PA and Sarah Boden of WESA
BOLIVAR โ Kim Botteicher decided to speak out about her work offering syringe services in Westmoreland County, hoping to prompt change that she believes would help save lives.
But after she went public, county government officials pulled $150,000 in opioid settlement funding they had approved for her organization โ money Botteicher said she planned to spend on hiring additional staff to work with people who are dealing with addiction and recovery, as well as their families. None of the funds would have gone to syringe services, she said in January.
โWe need it desperately,โ Botteicher said of the money.
The funding gap complicates plans for her nonprofit to provide emergency housing and other community programs, said Botteicher. FAVOR ~ Western PA, a recovery community organization that runs support groups, is based in a cloistered pocket of rural Pennsylvania that lacks a number of safety net services.
Botteicher’s situation highlights a conflict between Pennsylvania laws and practices backed by leading medical groups, and it shows how local leaders are now left in charge of weighing the public health and legal consequences as they decide how to spend the stateโs windfall from settlements with opioid companies.
Syringe services programs โ which offer needles and other supplies that make it less risky to inject drugs โ have widespread support in the medical community. The CDC says nearly 30 years of research shows comprehensive syringe services programs โare safe, effective, and cost-saving, do not increase illegal drug use or crime, and play an important role in reducing the transmission of viral hepatitis, HIV and other infections.โ The programs also can connect people to recovery services.
Expanding syringe services is listed as one of the โCore Strategiesโ for the tens of billions of dollars coming to states as part of settlements with drug companies for their role in allegedly fueling the opioid epidemic. A coalition of state attorneys general, including now-Gov. Josh Shapiro, negotiated the agreements.
But Pennsylvaniaโs drug paraphernalia law makes it significantly harder for opioid settlement money to directly support expanding syringe services in many places. People who run syringe services programs often must do so in the shadows, as they risk arrest. The programs are widely considered illegal in most of the state.
โItโs just a huge inconsistency,โ said Zoe Soslow, who leads overdose prevention work in Pennsylvania for the public health organization Vital Strategies. โItโs causing a lot of confusion.โ
Soslow and other supporters of expanding syringe services say the situation in Westmoreland County highlights the need to change state law.
โItโs fundamentally the problem we have in PA and still some other states where the legal doubts about syringe exchange have not been completely erased, even after 30 years of successful life-saving operation,โ said Scott Burris, an attorney and director of the Center for Public Health Law Research at Temple University.
Westmoreland County officials acknowledged legal concerns were a factor in their decision to pull FAVORโs funding. Commissioner Douglas Chew told Spotlight PA and WESA that the county โis very risk-averse.โ
โThereโs a lot of gray area in this, and if we were to end up in a lawsuit, the litigation costs would be enormous,โ said Chew. โAnd itโs just not worth taking that risk on for my taxpayers.โ
While syringe services are on the list of approved and recommended uses for opioid settlement money, Chew said, โthe state of Pennsylvania doesnโt seem to be aligned with that.โ
โAnd we would, as a county government, have to follow all of the laws within our commonwealth,โ he added.
Funding pulled
Last November, Spotlight PA and WESA featured Botteicher in a story examining the conflict about syringe services in the state. As the executive director of FAVOR, Botteicher helps people in addiction and recovery find housing and jobs, and connects them with long-term treatment. She told Spotlight PA and WESA that providing syringes is a way to support people in โa very whole wayโ and to minimize harm.
But syringes ultimately caused problems for her.
In October 2023, county commissioners approved providing $150,000 to FAVOR as part of the countyโs opioid settlement plan. Meeting minutes described the money as part of the funding to โRecovery Community Organizations for Community Peer Support.โ Documents from the opioid settlements between states and drug companies describe approved uses for the funds, and they specifically include peer support services and counseling, along with connections to community-based services.
The October meeting minutes and related resolution did not mention syringe services. Botteicher told Spotlight PA and WESA in November that she had other money and resources available to offer syringe services, separate from the opioid settlement funds from the county.
But on Dec. 21, county commissioners unanimously approved rescinding the agreement with FAVOR, meeting minutes show.
โItโs incredibly disheartening,โ said Soslow of Vital Strategies.
Vital Strategies is providing funding to FAVOR for an electronic health record system to help the organization track the services it delivers. Financial support from Vital Strategies will also go toward the purchase of a vehicle that will help FAVOR take people to doctorโs appointments, court dates, and other places they need to go.
โFAVOR is in an incredibly rural part of the state with an immense need,โ said Soslow. โTheyโre doing incredible work saving peopleโs lives.โ
In January, Botteicher celebrated FAVORโs expansion into a second location in Bolivar. The organization purchased a former Methodist church, which Botteicher intends to use as an emergency shelter. She said a person waiting to enter treatment recently stayed overnight at the building, sleeping on a couch. And Botteicher has bigger plans, including renovating the building.
รThe goal is to help others who are waiting to get into detox and treatment programs, as well as individuals and families waiting for permanent housing.
But maintaining a shelter would require at least occasional overnight employees, estimated Botteicher, who said her current staff who provide recovery assistance are already โstretched to the max.โ The loss of county funding leaves FAVOR unable to hire two more employees as planned, she said.
The former church would also be open to the broader community, not only those seeking help for addiction issues, Botteicher said. She imagines the building functioning like a senior center, where people can play cards, do a puzzle, and participate in a book club.
The building is already being used to host meetings for a youth program, but Botteicher said in an email that โwithout the extra employees I don’t even have the staff to open it up for the seniors and the community every day.โ
She plans to pursue other funding options.
โWe will keep plugging away,โ she said. โThatโs not going to change.โ
Rob Hamilton, director of human services for Westmoreland County, was one of the featured speakers at the FAVOR celebration in January, during which he discussed his own long-term recovery. He said he hopes opioid settlement money goes to Botteicherโs peer-support work in the future.
โWe need recovery organizations like this here, ready, willing, and able to assist those that need it the most,โ Hamilton said of FAVOR.
Tim Phillips, the director of a Westmoreland County department tasked with reducing the impact of opioid addiction and preventing the spread of communicable diseases, also showed up in Bolivar to celebrate FAVOR. He said the decision to cut its funding was โunfortunate,โ but necessary given the legal status of syringe services in the state.
Phillips told Spotlight PA and WESA that heโd like to see local officials find a way to allow syringe services, which officials in Philadelphia and Allegheny County did decades ago. He also said that sometimes the Westmoreland County government is โa little conservative,โ but that issues around substance-use disorder and harm reduction should not be political.
โI myself am a person in long-term recovery,โ he said. โIf I didnโt have the opportunity a long time ago to access appropriate and adequate treatment, I too could have become a statistic.โ
Calls and emails from Spotlight PA and WESA to two Westmoreland County commissioners โ Sean Kertes and Ted Kopas โ were not returned. Spotlight PA and WESA filed open records requests with the county in January relating to its opioid settlement funds and communications regarding FAVOR. The county invoked its right under the stateโs open records law to delay providing final responses by 30 days.
Legal risk
Pennsylvania expects to receive more than $1.6 billion in opioid settlement funds, a spokesperson for the attorney generalโs office told Spotlight PA and WESA in November. An advisory group of a 13-member oversight board for the funds has offered guidance on some questions for how the money can and cannot be spent, but the trustโs FAQ page didnโt address syringe services as of early February.
In many parts of the country, people have more clarity about syringe services. An August 2023 report by the Legislative Analysis and Public Policy Association found 38 states explicitly or implicitly authorize syringe services programs through statute or regulation. Pennsylvania is not one of them, but syringe services still operate in the state. Some providers have legal protections, while others donโt.
In 1992, Philadelphiaโs then-Mayor Ed Rendell, a Democrat, issued an executive order providing legal protections for people providing syringe services in that city. Allegheny County officials in the 2000s took similar action, citing a state law that gives certain powers to counties that have created their own health departments.
The state Board of Pharmacy in 2009 changed its regulations to permit pharmacists to sell hypodermic needles and syringes to people without a prescription. In making the change, the board cited the โcompelling public health interest in reducing the spread of hepatitis C and HIV.โ
But Pennsylvaniaโs drug laws still say syringes are illegal drug paraphernalia if they are used or are intended to be used to inject banned controlled substances.
Burris, the Temple researcher, has argued that the stateโs drug paraphernalia ban was never intended to apply to people offering syringe services for public health reasons. But he said there havenโt been court cases in Pennsylvania to clarify the true protections and risks that exist.
โThereโs an easy solution here,โ Burris said. โAll Harrisburg has to do is repeal or amend the drug paraphernalia law so itโs clear โ or even clearer, I should say โ that syringe-exchange programs are legal.โ
In the Pennsylvania House, a bill that would create an exception for syringe services programs in the stateโs drug paraphernalia law awaits action in the Judiciary Committee. The chair of the committee, Democrat Tim Briggs of Montgomery County, previously told Spotlight PA and WESA he supports legalizing syringe services. In late January, he said he hopes to add the bill to the committeeโs next voting meeting agenda in a few weeks.
Botteicher said she still believes syringe services programs are a critical harm-reduction tool.
โItโs right. Itโs good. And it works,โ Botteicher told Spotlight PA and WESA.
โWe need these laws changed.โ
WHILE YOUโRE HEREโฆ If you learned something from this story, pay it forward and become a member of Spotlight PA so someone else can in the future at spotlightpa.org/donate. Spotlight PA is funded by foundations and readers like you who are committed to accountability journalism that gets results.