At a relatively small school like Annville-Cleona, success in athletics – or the lack thereof – can often be attributed to simply the number of healthy bodies a team has at its disposal in a given season.
In other words, you gotta have numbers if you want to be competitive.
No one needs to tell anyone in the Annville-Cleona football program that. First under longtime head coach Terry Lehman and the last eight years with A-C alum Matt Gingrich guiding the program, very few local athletic programs have done more with less.
That’s because what it lacks in quantity, it always seems to make up for in quality.
For example, due to graduation losses, the Dutchmen said goodbye to 21 players from last season’s District 3 2A runner-up squad.
Such heavy graduation losses would be devastating to even much larger school districts. But A-C keeps rolling merrily along, shrugging off the almost annual depletion of its roster to again field a team capable of competing with just about any opponent on a given night.
Somehow, Gingrich and his staff were able to all but fill those vacant spots on the depth chart to again field a roster of nearly 40 players
“We lost 21 kids,” said Gingrich last week. “We were really worried about the numbers, but we’ll end up with 38, 39, 40, 41 kids. We did pick up a lot of kids. Numbers-wise we’ve rebounded nicely.”
“The biggest thing I would say is I feel we have some top-level talent for our size of school. The biggest concern would be the development of the backups, and the 15th, 16th and 17th player on offense. Because we just lost so many kids. There’s a lot of bright spots, but there’s gonna be a lot of depth issues.”
Among, the key departures lost to graduation were 2,000-yard rusher Phoenix Music and linebacker/slot Alex Long, who has taken his game to the college level at Robert Morris. A-C must also replace the cool- headed leadership of departed quarterback Gavin Keller.
Cam Connolly a senior, steps into Keller’s shoes to lead the offense, while senior Cael Harter will take on the responsibility of being the main ball carrier from Music. Junior Bryce Keller, meanwhile, leads a four-man battle for the starting fullback job, while another 11th-grader, Jon Shay, also a defensive standout, figures to grab the starting spot at wing back. Senior Darien Holloway lines up at tight end in A-C’s veer attack.
On the O-line, the center will be junior Preston Bomgardner, while Damien Miller and Alex Hemperly will man the guard spots, and Malacai Victa and Alec Tetzlaff handle the tackle duties, and Adam Kwiatkowski the tackle jobs.
Handling the receiving jobs will be Cash Watson, Dominic Cascotti and Jack Getty. Gavin Martens also is in the mix at receiver.
Defensively, A-C will line up with Victa and Miller at the tackles. Jackson Speece, a freshman, and Anthony Garner will also see time inside while Tim Montijo and Jon Shay, one of three returnees with over 100 tackles a season ago, hold down the end duties.
Holloway, another 100-tackle kid, will be the middle linebacker, while the outside jobs could go to Hemperly and Hudson Sellers and Jon Moran along with Ryan Barrientos.
Connolly and Wyatt Mace will be at safety and joined in the secondary by Harter, the third returning player with 100 tackles last season, and Cascotti at the corners. The place kicking duties will go to soccer player Mina Elzek.
“We do have the parts, we do have the pieces,” said Gingrich. “We’re really trying to find (what position) to put these kids to accentuate their positives.”
Whether or not the Dutchmen can get to the level required to compete for titles in Lancaster-Lebanon Section 5 and District 3 2A remains to be seen, but the effort and commitment to do so figures to be there once again. A-C will begin that quest Friday against Hanover.
“You make the district final and things change,” Gingrich said, only half-kidding. “The kids are like, ‘We gotta get back, we gotta get back.’ I said, ‘You don’t worry about that. You worry about getting better every day.'”
Scenes from a preseason practice for Annville-Cleona football in August 2023. (Will Trostel) Scenes from a preseason practice for Annville-Cleona football in August 2023. (Will Trostel) Alex Hemperly, junior, offensive lineman and linebacker, performing drills with Coach Joe Shay. (Will Trostel) Scenes from a preseason practice for Annville-Cleona football in August 2023. (Will Trostel) Scenes from a preseason practice for Annville-Cleona football in August 2023. (Will Trostel) Jack Getty, a junior wide receiver, defensive back, running routes. (Will Trostel) 
Coach Joe Heckard oversees A-C offensive players. (Will Trostel) Scenes from a preseason practice for Annville-Cleona football in August 2023. (Will Trostel) Coach Jon Bopp oversees defensive line drills. (Will Trostel)
Annville-Cleona Dutchmen
Read all our coverage of the Dutchmen here.
Roster
Head Coach: Matt Gingrich
Assistant Coaches: Joe Heckard, Greg Keener, Joe Shay, Jon Bopp, Drew Speraw, Cody Dodson, Jonathan Lum, Mike Miller
| Jersey Number | Name | Grade | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Miles Riehl | 11 | WR/DB |
| 2 | Cash Watson | 12 | WR/DB |
| 3 | Carson Grow | 12 | WR/DB |
| 4 | Cael Harter | 12 | RB/DB |
| 6 | Noah Riehl | 10 | WR/DB |
| 7 | Wyatt Mase | 10 | QB/DB |
| 8 | Liam Pulaski | 12 | WR/DB |
| 9 | Gavin Martens | 10 | WR/DB |
| 10 | Jonas Cupak | 11 | WR/DB |
| 11 | Bryce Keller | 11 | RB/DB |
| 13 | Ryan Barrientos | 11 | RB/LB |
| 14 | Jonathan Moran | 10 | RB/LB |
| 16 | Cameron Connelly | 12 | QB/DB |
| 17 | Kaeli Pennington | 11 | WR/DB |
| 19 | Yamaliel Navarro | 9 | RB/DB |
| 21 | Mina Elzek | 12 | K |
| 22 | Aidan Blauch | 11 | WR/DB |
| 24 | Hudson Sellers | 10 | RB/LB |
| 31 | Dominic Casciotti | 11 | WR/DB |
| 33 | Luke Wentling | 10 | RB/LB |
| 35 | Jack Getty | 11 | WR/DB |
| 36 | Ivan Kreider | 11 | TE/LB |
| 41 | Jonathon Shay | 11 | RB/DL |
| 44 | Levi Heckard | 10 | TE/DL |
| 50 | Dan Bright-Walck | 10 | OL/DL |
| 51 | Alex Hemperly | 11 | OL/LB |
| 52 | Damien Miller | 12 | OL/DL |
| 53 | Anthony Gardner | 12 | OL/DL |
| 54 | Malacai Victa | 11 | OL/DL |
| 55 | Travis Wilk | 10 | OL/DL |
| 59 | Jordan Nickens | 10 | OL/DL |
| 64 | Armani Santos | 10 | OL/DL |
| 68 | Nathanael Sanchez | 10 | OL/DL |
| 70 | Blake Meyer | 10 | OL/DL |
| 72 | Alec Tetzlaff | 12 | OL/DL |
| 75 | Carter Smith | 12 | OL/DL |
| 76 | Preston Bomgardner | 11 | OL/DL |
| 77 | Jaxon Speece | 9 | OL/DL |
| 87 | Darrian Holloway | 12 | TE/LB |
| 89 | Timothy Montijo | 12 | RB/DL |
Questions about this story? Suggestions for a future LebTown article? Reach our newsroom using this contact form and we’ll do our best to get back to you.
Free news isn’t cheap. If you value the journalism LebTown provides to the community, then help us make it sustainable by becoming a champion of local news. You can unlock additional coverage for the community by supporting our work with a one-time contribution, or joining as a monthly or annual member. You can cancel anytime.
