Cornwall Borough resident Bruce Chadbourne moved to Cornwall Manor a few years ago after his retirement, drawn by the history of the mine and the Cornwall Iron Furnace. He has taken to writing a few historical articles, which he’s kindly shared with LebTown for our readers to enjoy in a semi-regular series titled, “Who knew?” We hope you enjoy.

The Riddle

It happened again, this cold November day as I walked my dog on the Lebanon Valley Rail Trail, just as it had last year. A riddle presented itself for the curious and clever: “Here in Cornwall, what is gray, disappears in spring and reappears in fall?” 

Perhaps you already know the answer. When walking the trail south beyond the old iron railroad trestle, you may discern a ghostly gray shape down amongst the trees to your right. You must be paying attention because it pops up and within a few steps it’s gone.

Furthermore, the phenomenon happens not just once but three times as you walk along. What IS that? By the way, as spring turns into summer – it just won’t happen at all. Nothing to see, move along folks!

Care for a swim, anyone?

Though it looks like an overgrown wooded area that deer are known to inhabit, there is more than meets the eye. Once when examining a local topographic map I was surprised to see three rectangular pools right in the midst of Cornwall Manor’s “The Woods” campus.

Rising to the challenge

I had no idea what those pools on the map were for. But late last winter curiosity finally got the better of me, so I trudged through the snowy woods to go find those strange gray shapes. It was the proper time for bushwhacking, with the undergrowth reduced by autumn and winter. Spring was approaching so the ground was soft and slippery in spots, and ice was turning to slush.

As I left my backyard the terrain soon dropped off into the sanctuary of the first pool. Artificial berms define each side. On later dog-walks in the neighborhood it became easy to notice these berms extending down behind the houses. Who knew, my neighbors enjoy waterfront property with an Olympic-sized swimming pool in their backyard!

About 150 feet through the first pool stands an old concrete cofferdam, not quite 6 feet tall, arched backward to provide strength in holding back water. Old pieces of rusted iron protruded from the concrete. 

The sloping sides on the downstream side of the cofferdam explained the angular shapes I had been seeing through the trees from the rail trail.

I trekked down further to another pair of berms, truncated by a second cofferdam. Continuing further I found the third pool, again complete with berms and cofferdam. This lowest section was quite marshy, with dead cattails bobbing and weaving in the slight breeze. There were plenty of deer tracks around; the only sound was the chirping of the early birds on a sunny afternoon. The cold winter air was clean; not many spring odors were registering in my nose. As I looked up through the trees, the sky was a pretty, soft blue punctuated with cottonball clouds. 

Somewhat satisfied with my find I returned home, yet still in a fog. What the heck are these things? How do they fit into the local history of furnaces, mines, and railroads?

[Editor’s Note: If you go to see the “pools” please remain on the Rail Trail. The adjacent land is private property and is preserved for deer and other wildlife.]

Answers come to those who wait

On those daily dog walks I’ve collected a few other puzzling pieces. A rusty open-ended iron pipe sticks out of the road bank behind my house. Half-buried in the dirt nearby is a long companion section of rusted pipe. Further, immediately behind my neighbor’s sun porch, rests a concrete abutment with a large industrial pipe fitting.

The puzzle pieces dropped into place when I put the question to a colleague at the Cornwall Iron Furnace, where I volunteer. Mike Weber, our own professional geologist known for his excellent history webinars on the Cornwall ore deposit, gave me the answer. Mike has also been researching the history of Bethlehem Steel in Cornwall. 

Briefly, Bethlehem Steel came to town starting in 1916, purchasing the various furnaces, buying other small steel companies, and also acquiring a controlling share in the Cornwall Mine, aided by their significant profits from World War I. By 1921 they had shut down the local anthracite furnaces and were instead sending ore to their steel mills in the region.

At that time the open pit mine was getting deeper (460 feet) and narrower so the miners drilled shaft No. 3 under the open pit in pursuit of deeper ore to a level of 740 feet. The shaft entrance was between Middle and Grassy Hill, and the access road is in Burd Coleman Village, nearly opposite to the entrance to “The Woods,” where the stone mason’s property stands today. The large piles of waste rock along Burd Coleman Road came out of No. 3 mine over decades of operation.

Wait for it…

Yes, yes, about those mysterious swimming pools. The No. 3 mine first operated from 1927 to 1941 and then paused for several years to avoid interfering with open pit mining up above. After World War II new winds were blowing. Underground operations were resuming in Mine No. 3. The year before the Methodists opened a retirement community in 1949,  the Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 prompted the commonwealth of Pennsylvania to require the regulation of water discharges from the mine. The state subsequently approved the construction of three settling ponds for Mine No. 3, which were completed on June 12, 1951.

The settling ponds performed as needed. Samples of the water pumped from No. 3 Mine had 74,306 parts per million (ppm) of suspended solids and a pH of 7.6. By the time the water flowed down that iron pipe in my back yard, through the valve behind my neighbor’s house, and into the three cascading settling ponds, the discharge from the final pond as it entered Snitz Creek had only 14 parts per million suspended solids and a pH of 8.2. That’s 99.98% reduction, water that is “purer” than Ivory soap!

As life in Cornwall moved on into 1972, Hurricane Agnes caused serious problems for Lebanon County, including the cessation of mining operations. The settling ponds no longer served a purpose, and over the last 50 years trees have rendered them unseen. When the Woods Campus started building in 2004, they were left undisturbed. You might have never known, but courtesy of Mike Weber we have both explanations and photos.

Photo showing the pools, circa 1950. (Michael Trump)

Epilogue: a pictorial history

First, we see the site under construction with the prefabricated dams on location (c.1951). Notice the railroad, the trestle, and the former furnace “office” on the hill where Cornwall Manor resident Lee McMindes later lived for many years. This tract of land today forms part of Cornwall Manor’s “The Woods” campus.

On June 12, 1951, the settling ponds were placed in operation – the next photo shows several men at the inlet valve watching the first water flow into the first pond. With their backs to the southwest, immediately to their left is my neighbor’s house (not seen until 2004) and my house immediately behind them. In the upper left corner the railroad runs down toward Mount Gretna.

 Another view, looking southwest from the final of the three ponds. Notice – no trees!

Finally, a later view looking north from Burd Coleman Road at the settling ponds in full operation.

Final “Epilog” photos supplied from the 1951 annual report of the Cornwall Division, Bethlehem Mines Corp., courtesy of Mike Weber.


Questions about this story? Suggestions for a future LebTown article? Reach our newsroom using the contact form below and we’ll do our best to get back to you.

Do you support local news?
If you believe that Lebanon County needs independent, high-quality journalism, consider joining LebTown as a member. Your support will go directly towards stories like this and you will be helping ensure that our community has a reliable news source for years to come.

Learn more about membership and join now here.