Will you support independent, non-partisan journalism?

Become a champion of local news and unlock additional benefits as a LebTown member, like exclusive members-only emails, access to comments, invitations to members-only events, and more.

Make an impact. Cancel anytime.

Already a member? Login here

The state has reached a settlement with the estate of Andy Dzwonchyk over the November 2021 shooting of Dzwonchyk by a Pennsylvania State Police trooper.

Paul Messing, a partner in civil rights law firm Kairys, Rudovsky, Messing & Feinberg, said that the Dzwonchyk estate will receive $1.75 million.

As first reported by the New York Times in January, Dzwonchyk was the fourth Pennsylvanian to be fatally shot by Trooper Jay Splain. The first fatal shooting occurred in Lehigh County in 2007; the second in Northampton County in 2017. The third occurred in Lebanon County in March 2020, when Splain shot Charity Thome in Jackson Township following a car chase through the county. 

Messing said that no amount of money is going to bring Dzwonchyk back, but his children lost both their father and their principal means of support, and the settlement amount ensures they will be taken care of.

Messing said he was very pleased that the settlement was able to be reached quickly, on Thursday, Sept. 1, just three days after Lebanon County District Attorney Pier Hess Graf cleared Splain of any criminal wrongdoing.

“We have been monitoring the situation for many months and we have been in discussion with the state for some time to amicably resolve this issue to get the children the support they need,” said Messing.

Messing said that Hess Graf’s report was worded more towards character assassination than proving the shooting was justified.

The DA’s report says that members of Dzwonchyk’s family refused to give statements to both the Pennsylvania State Police and the Lebanon County Detectives Bureau.

Messing said that nobody has attempted to interview members of Dzwonchyk’s family since the day after the shooting.

“As far as we can tell, there does not appear to have been a meaningful and comprehensive investigation,” said Messing.

As previously reported by LebTown, the DA’s report leaves open several core questions, such as how Splain could safely discharge a Taser or firearm into Dzwonchyk more than half a dozen times while he was struggling with another officer partially in the vehicle.

Read More: DA says Nov. 2021 shooting of Andy Dzwonchyk by PSP trooper was justified

“I hope the state police take action to hold the trooper accountable,” said Messing.

Email inquiries to the Pennsylvania State Police and the Pennsylvania Office of the Attorney General did not receive an immediate response Friday afternoon. An email to Hess Graf also did not receive an immediate response Friday afternoon.

In August 2021, Philadelphia law firm Kline and Specter filed a federal civil rights lawsuit on behalf of the Thome estate against Splain. Kline and Specter attorney Benjamin Present said that there have been no settlement discussions related to the Thome case.

Update: A spokesperson from the state AG’s office said that their office did not represent PSP or Trooper Splain in this case. A spokesperson from PSP confirmed a $1.75 million settlement over the November 2021 member involved shooting but had no further comment.

DA Hess Graf also responded to an email asking about the Dzwonchyk family’s assertion that they weren’t contacted. Her response is in full below:

“The approximately 50 page report covers the attempts to contact and interview the family. The State Police made its own contact and effort. Our Office did so, in person, within this building. Brothers of the decedent have pending criminal charges. They were all present for preliminary hearings; their mother, and mother of the decedent, was also present. I spoke with the brothers and explained we wished to interview them individually as to any information they may have. Chief Jon Hess was part of the conversation and we handed out business cards. He identified himself as the Chief of the Detective Bureau, explained we were conducting our investigation, and reiterated our desire to interview any of the family who wished to speak to us. We explained they could contact Chief Hess and set up a time to speak to him anytime. While the brothers appeared they wanted to do, the decedent’s mother intervened and said ‘no.’ She indicated she spoke for the family as a whole, no one would be contacting us, and we would be hearing from their attorney. She gathered her family and walked towards the elevator. I did not see any of the family in the building again that day. None of the family members thereafter scheduled time to meet with us. We do not continuously hound persons who state they do not wish to speak to law enforcement. Again Chief Hess remained present throughout the entire interaction.”

Do you want to see more from LebTown?

Free news isn’t cheap. If you value the journalism LebTown provides to the community, then help us make it sustainable by becoming a champion of local news.

You can unlock additional coverage for the community by supporting our work with a one-time contribution, or joining as a monthly or annual member. You can cancel anytime.

Questions about this story? Suggestions for a future LebTown article? Reach our newsroom using the contact form below and we’ll do our best to get back to you.

Davis Shaver

Davis Shaver is the publisher of LebTown. He grew up in Lebanon and currently lives outside of Hershey, PA.